Reseñas proporcionadas por Syndetics
Library Journal Review
An award-winning journalist and former Northern Editor of the Irish Times and Sunday Tribune, Moloney describes the delicate political maneuvering of Sinn Fein's Gerry Adams, which compelled the Provisional Irish Republican Army ultimately to accept what their constitution explicity forbade: a cease-fire in the fight to unify Ireland. Airing details of IRA political infighting for the first time, Moloney grants the lion's share of credit for the growing peace to Adams. Adams is the master insider, politician, and statesman who manipulated violence and the promise of peace in negotiations with England, Ireland, Ulster, and, to a lesser degree, America. By creating an internal bureaucracy that produced volumes of reports, more than the Army Council could digest, Adams kept control of the laborious negotiations. His greatest challenge, and success, was keeping the rank-and-file IRA in the dark about precisely what he was doing and how, working toward the cease-fire. The final push was the 9/11 attack, when the IRA dumped its weapons for fear of being lumped politically with al Qaeda by the Bush administration. Historians may ultimately apportion the credit differently, but Moloney does capture an important part of the process. For academic libraries and larger public collections.-Robert Moore, Bristol-Myers Squibb Medical Imaging, Billerica, MA (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Publishers Weekly Review
Most of this sure-to-be controversial narrative centers on the activities of Gerry Adams, who, over the course of his long IRA career, moved the organization away from the gun and toward a negotiated settlement with its British and Loyalist enemies. Moloney, an award-winning Irish journalist, begins with the crucial 1969 split between the Provisional IRA (PIRA), which championed armed struggle, and the socialist-leaning Official IRA. As a youth in Belfast, Adams joined the PIRA, and worked his way up through the ranks. As leader, he revamped the PIRA, starting in the 1980s, by altering its military structure while moving it into the political arena. Adams's strategy of utilizing both the bullet and the ballot, as Moloney repeatedly argues, led to inherent contradictions. Military operations, especially if they resulted in dead civilians, weakened Sinn Fein, the PIRA's political wing. In 1982, according to Moloney (years earlier than previously reported), Adams further eroded the militarists' influence by entering into secret peace negotiations with the Irish and British governments. Over the course of 16 years, Adams did the unthinkable and demilitarized Irish politics, but Moloney seems less than appreciative of Adams's achievements. His Adams is a Machiavellian figure who outmaneuvered and sold out the militarists within the PIRA. Some readers might conclude though Moloney never states it outright that Adams was the unnamed high-level IRA informer who, Moloney reports, tipped off the British to some IRA military operations. Whether Moloney is right or wrong about Adams, he's written an exhaustive and highly provocative account of the inner workings of the Provisionals. 16 pages of photos, 5 maps. (Nov.) Forecast: The U.S. embargo on this will be lifted the first week of October and will be coordinated with international publication. With potentially explosive revelations, this should receive major media attention and big sales. (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
CHOICE Review
Noted Irish journalist Moloney goes behind the scenes to trace the background to the northern Irish "peace process" and the resultant 1998 Good Friday Agreement that provides for a power sharing Protestant-Unionist and Catholic-nationalist government in Northern Ireland. Readers will be fascinated by his accounts of Irish Republican Army organization and operations. Gerry Adams is the central figure in Moloney's account, and a Machiavellian one at that, often speaking out of both sides of his mouth to manipulate groups with conflicting views. Catholic Father Alec Reid is featured as a secret go-between in hidden negotiations, which, over many years, oriented the Catholic nationalist movements toward a peaceful negotiation process and away from military activities and violence to achieve their goal of a united Ireland. Moloney's extensive access to confidential statements by republican activists provides considerable zest to his story. The author may prove to be overly optimistic regarding the reality of the IRA's decommissioning of their weapons stashes and the stability that actually results from the Good Friday Agreement, but the decline in violence is a remarkable development. Appendixes help with chronology, terms, people, and sources. Graduate students and faculty will find this to be high-quality investigative journalism. ^BSumming Up: Highly recommended. Upper-division undergraduates and above. J. W. Auld emeritus, California State University, Dominguez Hills
Booklist Review
Although to Americans this epic undertaking may appear as coming out of the blue, in Northern Ireland its publication is anticipated with trepidation by some of its subjects. But although his book definitely unearths some buried information--including details on Libyan arms deals and clandestine diplomacy between the IRA and Margaret Thatcher, the Catholic Church, and even the Clinton administration--the author's real focus is not so much the crimes of war as the foundations of peace. Concentrating primarily on the modern IRA and the events of the past 35 years, he treads carefully across dangerous ground, steadily building his thesis that Gerry Adams, the Sinn Fein leader and IRA Army Council member, was the dominant force in the Irish peace process from inception to conclusion. Moloney, a former editor and reporter who in 1999 was named Irish Journalist of the Year, provides considerable historical background and demonstrates a clear understanding of the often-byzantine machinations of the revolutionary group. The endless names and minute level of detail, however, mean this is not the best work for those seeking an introduction to the Troubles. Nor is the author a stylist; few of his passages convey the maelstrom of shootings and bombings in human terms. But in amassing and reinterpreting such a wealth of information, he does a great service to those who struggle to learn the facts so that they might figure out what it all meant. --Keir Graff