Reseñas proporcionadas por Syndetics
Library Journal Review
A generation ago, trained church historians wrote the bulk of histories of Christianity dry works that focused on theology, doctrinal debate, preaching, and the like. Journalists, however, have come to dominate the field with their unprecedented honesty, color, and verve. Moynahan, a writer for a variety of British newspapers and the author of the well-respected biography of Rasputin, The Saint Who Sinned, understands that the history of Christianity is not all about piety. With more than 100 startling photographs, illustrations, and drawings, he presents an unconventional and sensational chronology that reveals how Christianity has often been its own worst enemy. The story begins, dramatically enough, with Jesus on the cross, lamenting God's absence, and ends after 766 pages with a cutting statement: "Christianity's self-inflicted wounds still fester." In between, readers are exposed to every ugly event of Christianity imaginable: Roman persecution, Constantine's conquest of the church, heresy, Islamic invasions, slavery, crusades, inquisitions, the Bible as a lethal weapon, persecution by the Reformers, witch trials, conquistadors, persecution of missionaries, revolutions, fights between religions, and the African slave trade. Moynahan's latest is bloody, exciting, masterfully written, and recommended for all libraries. James A. Overbeck, Atlanta-Fulton P.L., GA (c) Copyright 2010. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Publishers Weekly Review
This mammoth book offers a proficient survey of the checkered history of Christianity from its origins to the 21st century. In an engaging voice, journalist Moynahan (The Saint Who Sinned) narrates the story of this upstart Mediterranean religious sect as it developed from a band of ragged disciples with no place to call home to a sophisticated organization with a well-defined priestly hierarchy and often magnificent buildings. He discusses the usual cast of characters from Jesus and Paul to Augustine, Luther, Calvin, Wesley and Pope John Paul II. He argues that the impulse to convert those outside of Christianity is central to the development of the faith, but uses the Crusades and the Spanish Inquisition to demonstrate how this impulse sometimes got out of hand. Moynahan discusses in helpful detail the origins of Islam in the context of the Islamic invasions of Christian Constantinople in the seventh century. However, the book suffers from a lack of balance. Moynahan lavishes attention on Christianity from its beginnings up through the Reformation for the first two-thirds of the book, but then hurries through the establishment of Christianity in America and the development of modern Christianity. Even more perplexing is the complete absence of any examination of Eastern Christianity from its beginnings to the iconoclast crises in the eighth and ninth centuries. In the end, these are minor quibbles with a book that tells crisply, with more than 100 b&w illustrations, a moving tale of the internal and external struggles of Christianity to establish and sustain its religious identity. (Apr.) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
CHOICE Review
Any one-volume work on Christianity's 2000-year history is a literary achievement in itself. Moynahan's beautifully produced book is a stylistic tour de force, impeccably phrased and intelligently proportioned. Without being superficial, however, it does have a surface-skimming quality, perhaps because it takes a gossip column approach to the protagonists of the story. Although inquisitors and corrupt clerics abound, and despite whole chapters on the wars of religion and witch hunts, there is barely a mention of Thomas Aquinas and the Council of Trent, for example, and the list of saints is brief. The general historical background of the various periods is well presented and helpful. However, anyone looking for an overarching insight into the core heartbeat of Christianity, its theological and religious soul, the "faith" of the book's title, will have to look elsewhere. In brief, a good read of one aspect of an important story. Recommended for general readers, upper-division undergraduates, and above. R. W. Rousseau University of Scranton